Wednesday, August 27, 2008

Variation

The CC's Dad suggested he do a post on this subject, and it's a terribly important subject. The CC is mortified that he didn't think of it himself.

What's the subject again? Variation.

There are two approaches to this subject, and we're going to explore them logically.

The first is that the chef is going to produce an exact product, and that everything is in the service of that. The CC has pontificated about the subject enough, and if you've lost your memory or your marbles, you can read about it here.

The second is that the chef explore the local variation in ingredients, and shape the recipe to his or her environment. Even to the point, the chef shapes the recipe to his or her mood.

Are you in a spicy mood tonight? Well, the CC doesn't know, my love, but he sure wants to find out how spicy you are.

Of course, this is a way for lazy people to be, well, lazy, but there's a difference between a minor variation based on a difference in ingredients, and just not bothering to follow the recipe at all.

What the CC is getting at is simple. Each recipe has a core, call it a soul if you will. Violate what makes the recipe tick and the CC will call you lazy; a mere variation at the edges is a variation. Of course, true mastery means that you make every variation come out exactly the way you want it to every single time.

There is an inherent tension between mastery and variation. The CC claims that you should just embrace it.

2 comments:

Unknown said...

So this brings to mind a question... where does the 'true' innovation come from? Would it be a constant sequence of slight variations as a recipe travels the world? Perhaps that is how it happened before the days of mass transportation and the internet, but not as much now.

Where does Adria lie on the spectrum? Is he a true innovator or not?

ShockingSchadenfreude said...

This is an excellent question, and like all excellent questions demands a serious and studied response (which the CC will provide but it requires some time and effort.)

For the record, the second question is much easier.

Ferran Adrià is a true innovator. Pure genius. The rest are but mere copycats.